Un-popular opinion, we should have not re signed Judge.

The contract he turned down before the season was more then fare. Yes he had an amazing season no doubt. Yet for that amount of money n length its crazy. The guy is 30 n is a a 9 year deal. Do you think a 37,38 guy will be playing great with that amount of cash, well no. Not to mention he hasnt always been healthy. For me a 6 year deal would have been perfect. I would have let him walk, n resigned Tallion.To make matters worse we still need pitching, n let a great pitcher walk, n gave a great player too much money n a nine year contract.

FanPosts are user-created content and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Pinstripe Alley writing staff or SB Nation.