clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Presenting the 2020 Yankees Roster Report Cards

New, 2 comments

A full player-by-player evaluation series on the 2020 Yankees.

Dan Brink/PSA Illustrations

The 2020 season has come to a close, and that means it’s time to recap the highs and lows of this strange year. After spending the first few weeks of the offseason reviewing game-specific highlights, we arrive at a favorite Pinstripe Alley tradition. The PSA staff is pleased to present the 2020 Yankees Roster Report Cards, our seventh installment in the yearly series.

We followed the same grading scheme as last year. For a refresher, the staff assigned a letter grade from A-F (or I for incomplete) to all 43 players who suited up for the Yankees this season. They used production, consistency, and performance relative to expectation as the grading benchmarks. The final grade was the average of those individual marks.


This post will serve as the tracker for the report cards, keeping the links to them in an easy-to-access location.

Miguel Andújar - D
Zack Britton - A
Luis Cessa - B
Aroldis Chapman - B+
Gerrit Cole - A
Thairo Estrada - D
Mike Ford - D-
Clint Frazier - A+
Deivi García - A-
Brett Gardner - B
Chad Green - A-
J.A. Happ - B-
Aaron Hicks - B+
Kyle Higashioka - A-
Jonathan Holder - B-
Aaron Judge - B+
Tommy Kahnle - I
Michael King - C-
DJ LeMahieu - A+
Jonathan Loaisiga - C+
Jordan Montgomery - C
Adam Ottavino - C-
James Paxton - F
Gary Sánchez - F
Giancarlo Stanton - A-
Masahiro Tanaka - B
Mike Tauchman - F
Gleyber Torres - C+
Gio Urshela - A
Luke Voit - A
Tyler Wade - C-

Misc. Rookie Pitchers
Misc. Relievers
Misc. Position Players

Community Grades


The series will run from November 2nd through December 9th. We’re looking forward to reviewing the season with you!