The Pinstripe Alley community’s Top 30 Yankees prospects

Three days ago, I put out a call for visitors to Pinstripe Alley to rank prospects using a one-to-one comparison system. There was an incredible response, as we received over 178,000 votes! Y’all clearly have feelings on the Yankees’ elite system, and you let us hear about it.

Tanya, Jason, and I did our own rankings with comments yesterday, but below are the results from the community poll. I expanded it to a Top 30 to offer a little more perspective. The number in parentheses is the score given by All Our Ideas based on the percentage of comparisons won.

1. Gleyber Torres, SS (97)
PSA prospect rank: 1

2. Clint Frazier, OF (95)
PSA prospect rank: 2

3. Blake Rutherford, OF (94)
PSA prospect rank: 5

4. James Kaprielian, RHP (92)
PSA prospect rank: 6

5. Aaron Judge, OF (90)
PSA prospect rank: 3

6. Justus Sheffield, LHP (89)
PSA prospect rank: 7

7. Jorge Mateo, SS (87)
PSA prospect rank: 4

8. Chance Adams, RHP (83)
PSA prospect rank: 8

9. Miguel Andujar, 3B (79)
PSA prospect rank: 9

10. Dustin Fowler, OF (76)
PSA prospect rank: 13

11. Jordan Montgomery, RHP (75)
PSA prospect rank: 11

12. Tyler Austin, 1B/OF (73)
PSA prospect rank: 16

13. Albert Abreu, RHP (73)
PSA prospect rank: 12

14. Domingo Acevedo, RHP (72)
PSA prospect rank: 10

15. Dillon Tate, RHP (71)
PSA prospect rank: 15

16. Tyler Wade, SS (71)
PSA prospect rank: 14

17. Ian Clarkin, LHP (69)
PSA prospect rank: 17

18. Jonathan Holder, RHP (63)
PSA prospect rank: N/A

19. Wilkerman Garcia, SS (61)
PSA prospect rank: N/A

20. Ben Heller, RHP (61)
PSA prospect rank: N/A

21. Dietrich Enns, LHP (59)
PSA prospect rank: 18

22. Domingo German, RHP (59)
PSA prospect rank: N/A

23. Kyle Higashioka, C (58)
PSA prospect rank: N/A

24. Kyle Holder, SS (55)
PSA prospect rank: N/A

25. J.P. Feyereisen, RHP (55)
PSA prospect rank: N/A

26. Billy McKinney, OF (55)
PSA prospect rank: 20

27. Dermis Garcia, 3B (50)
PSA prospect rank: N/A

28. Nick Green, RHP (45)
PSA prospect rank: Honorable mention

29. Drew Finley, RHP (45)
PSA prospect rank: 19

30. Jorge Guzman, RHP (44)
PSA prospect rank: N/A

Our rankings were actually quite close. There was some shuffling around in the middle of the top 10 and beyond, but most of the names were similar. What do you think about the final results of the rankings? Did you feel that the comparison system helped evaluate how you feel about the prospects? Would you be open to similar polls using this tool in the future?

Let us know in the comments.