clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Pinstripe Alley MLB Playoff Predictions

New, comments

Who does the Pinstripe Alley staff favor to go all the way?

Robert Hanashiro-USA TODAY Sports

Yesterday, I sent an e-mail out to the Pinstripe Alley staff asking for their thoughts on how they think the playoffs will go. Here are the questions I asked:

AL Wild Card playoff winner? (Royals or A's)
NL Wild Card playoff winner? (Giants or Pirates)

ALDS 1 winner? (how many games?) (Angels or Royals/A's)
ALDS 2 winner? (games?) (Orioles or Tigers)
NLDS 1 winner? (games?) (Nationals or Giants/Pirates)
NLDS 2 winner? (games?) (Dodgers or Cardinals)

ALCS winner? (games?)
ALCS MVP?
NLCS winner? (games?)
NLCS MVP?

World Series winner? (games?)
World Series MVP?

How many damn playoff homers?

***

Check out what everyone thought, and make your own predictions in the comments to see if you can beat us!


AL WC playoff NL WC playoff ALDS 1 ALDS 2 NLDS 1 NLDS 2 ALCS ALCS MVP NLCS NLCS MVP World Series WS MVP How many damn HR?
Tanya Royals Pirates Angels in 4 O's in 5 Nats in 4 Dodgers in 5 O's in 7 Jones Nats in 6 Rendon O's in 7 Cruz 43
Andrew Royals Giants Angels in 4 Tigers in 4 Nats in 3 Dodgers in 5 Tigers in 6 Scherzer Dodgers in 6 Kershaw Dodgers in 6 Kemp 47
Jason Royals Pirates Angels in 4 O's in 5 Nats in 5 Dodgers in 4 Angels in 6 Trout Nats in 7 Zimmermann Nats in 5 Desmond 15
Caitlin A's Pirates Angels in 4 O's in 5 Nats in 4 Dodgers in 5 Angels in 6 Trout Dodgers in 6 Ramirez Dodgers in 6 Kemp 27
Greg Royals Pirates Angels in 4 O's in 3 Pirates in 5 Dodgers in 5 O's in 6 Jones Pirates in 7 McCutchen Pirates in 6 McCutchen 13
Matt F. A's Giants Angels in 5 Tigers in 4 Nats in 5 Dodgers in 4 Tigers in 6 Scherzer Dodgers in 5 Gonzalez Dodgers in 6 Kershaw 54
Matt P. A's Pirates A's in 5 O's in 5 Pirates in 4 Cards in 4 O's in 6 Cruz Cards in 5 Wainwright O's in 6 Jones 37
Michael A's Giants A's in 5 Tigers in 4 Nats in 4 Dodgers in 3 A's in 7 Donaldson Dodgers in 6 Ramirez Dodgers in 6 Kershaw 52
Doug A's Pirates Angels in 5 Tigers in 4 Nats in 4 Dodgers in 5 Angels in 6 Trout Dodgers in 6 Kershaw Dodgers in 6
Kemp 23
Harlan Royals Pirates Angels in 4 Tigers in 5 Nats in 4 Dodgers in 5 Tigers in 6 J.D. Martinez Dodgers in 6 Greinke Dodgers in 7 Kershaw 42
John Royals Giants Angels in 4 O's in 5 Nats in 3 Dodgers in 5 Angels in 6 Weaver Dodgers in 5 Kemp Dodgers in 6 Gonzalez 33
Shaun Royals Pirates Royals in 5 Tigers in 4 Pirates in 3 Dodgers in 5 Tigers in 5 Cabrera Dodgers in 6 Kershaw Dodgers in 6 Puig 27
Chris A's Giants A's in 5 Tigers in 5 Nats in 4 Dodgers in 5 Tigers in 6 V. Martinez Nats in 7 Strasburg Nats in 7 Span 26
Bryan Royals Pirates Angels in 4 O's in 4 Nats in 3 Dodgers in 5 Angels in 7 Trout Dodgers in 6 Kemp Dodgers in 6 Kershaw 22
Jim A's Pirates A's in 5 O's in 4 Pirates in 5 Dodgers in 4 A's in 6 Gray Dodgers in 5 Kershaw Dodgers in 5 Puig 43
Scott A's Giants Angels in 5 O's in 4 Nats in 4 Dodgers in 4 Angels in 6 Pujols Nats in 6 Strasburg Nats in 6 Zimmermann 30
Majority None (8 each) Pirates (10) Angels (11) O's (9) Nats (12) Dodgers (15) Angels (6) Trout (4) Dodgers (10) Kershaw (4) Dodgers (10) Kershaw (4) 33 (avg.)