clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

The Manager All-Time Team

New, comments

As usual, I was sitting at my desk, thinking about baseball instead of working...

Here's the thought: which manager could field the best team based on players he had managed?  Is it a Joe McCarthy who managed a single team that dominated the league for years, or a better traveled manager like Joe Torre or Billy Martin, who managed a wider range of players?

Since I figure the great Yankee skipper will be well represented in the comments (Casey is my pick) I started looking at the non-Yankee options:

John J. McGraw Lou Pinella Bobby Cox Connie Mack Sparky Anderson
C Roger Bresnahan Geovany Soto Javy Lopez Mickey Cochrane Johnny Bench
1B Bill Terry Don Mattingly Fred McGriff Jimmy Foxx Tony Perez
2B Rogers Hornsby Brett Boone Marcus Giles Nap Lajoie Joe Morgan
3B Freddie Lindstrom Alex Rodriguez Chipper Jones Home Run Baker Pete Rose
SS Travis Jackson Barry Larkin Rafael Furcal Jack Barry Alan Trammell
LF Willie Keeler Rickey Henderson Dale Murphy Al Simmons George Foster
CF Fred Snodgrass Ken Griffey Jr. Andrew Jones Ty Cobb Chet Lemon
RF Mel Ott Dave Winfield Gary Sheffield Tris Speaker Kirk Gibson
SP Christy Matthewson Randy Johnson Phil Niekro Eddie Plank Jack Morris
SP Carl Hubbell Joe Niekro Gaylord Perry Lefty Grove Gary Nolan
SP Burleigh Grimes Carlos Zambrano Greg Maddux ? David Wells
SP Joe McGinnity Tommy John Tom Glavine ? Dan Petry
CP Rube Marquard Dave Righetti John Smoltz Chief Bender Willie Hernandez

Obviously, I'm taking the players' careers rather than a specific season. 

I think it's tough to beat Lou Pinella: although his starting pitching isn't as elite as Bobby Cox's, Lou has Ichiro and Carl Crawford to pinch run, Edgar Martinez to pinch hit, and he's got Willie Randolph for a defensive replacement.