clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

The Tools of Ignorance: Monday News

New, comments

While the Yankees continue the Cliff Lee vigil, it seems every other team in baseball is making moves:

Outside the AL East, the A's are closing in on Hideki Matsui, the Angels signed Scott Downs, and the White Sox added Adam Dunn to the core of veterans returning to the squad.

Frankly, I'm not terribly thrilled to see the Yanks' offseason hinge so completely on one signing.  It's not because of what I think about Cliff Lee, but because of what I think of our favorite loudmouth: Hank Steinbrenner.

Unlike Cashman, Hank seems like the kind of guy who is swayed by the media narrative, and if Lee signs with the Rangers or a mystery team, the narrative is certain to be "The Yankees failed to get their man." If this puts pressure on Cashman to spend too much on importing a starter, or to commit too much to a mediocre free agent, this quickly becomes the worst case scenario. There are a few pitchers rumored to be available that I would trade for at the right price.  There aren't really any free agent starters (after Lee) who have a chance of fulfilling the contract they'd likely sign. 

But I worry about narratives, because it's all to easy to fall into their spell for the people who spend their time listen, reading, and writing about the Yankees and baseball (myself included). Pavano was a pansy, RJ was lousy in pinstripes, Greinke only had one good year.  There is evidence to disprove each of those positions, but I hear them all on a regular basis.  Sometimes, when I'm upset or in a hurry, it's hard to resist the lure of a strong narrative. But that doesn't make it any more true.

The success or failure of the Yankees' offseason does not depend on the signing of any one player.  Say it three times, and click your heels together.