Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Bracketology 2012: Duke Finally Steps Up To The No. 1 Line

Yankee Stadium

Yankee Stadium Receives Low Ratings From Fans

Great picture.

NY Times Columnist Nate Silver wrote this article about fan ratings of MLB Stadiums and what we can learn from them. I definitely suggest reading the article, but here are some bullet points for those of you that don't want to.

-On a scale of 1 to 5 (five being the best) fans rated Yankee Stadium a 3.92, which ranks it 21st out of the 30 MLB Stadiums.

-Fenway Park ranked second overall, and Citi Field ranked 15th.

-The Old Yankee Stadium would have ranked tied for 20th with a 3.96 rating.

-Everyone loves PNC Park, (Home of the Pirates) so talent of the team does not necessarily determine how fans like the Stadium. I'm glad to see this.

Two quotes:

The funny one: I’m working on an article about the New York Mets — but that subject is perhaps too depressing for a beautiful Memorial Day weekend.

The interesting one:

One potential conclusion is that it’s not worth building a retractable roof (which often requires significant additional taxpayer expense.) The five stadiums which have one receive an average rating of 3.86, versus an average of 4.10 for those that remain open to the elements.

How would you rate the stadiums you have been to? How would Yankee Stadium rate? How could Yankee Stadium improve? Discuss.

Poll
How would you rate the New Yankee Stadium? (5 being best)
0
14 votes
1
13 votes
2
36 votes
3
76 votes
4
140 votes
5
145 votes

424 votes | Poll has closed

107 comments  | 

Review Of "The House Of Steinbrenner" 30 For 30

NEW YORK - APRIL 16:  The current Yankee Stadium is seen through the remaining structure of the old Yankee Stadium  prior to the New York Yankees hosting the Texas Rangers on April 16, 2010 in the Bronx borough of New York City.  (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images)

When checking the DVR for what to watch this morning, I noticed "The House Of Steinbrenner." With an hour to kill I decided to watch it.

The film was oddly put together, as director/producer Barbara Kopple often lost sight of her own goal within the film. To portray the Steinbrenners and Yankees tradition in film form.

Kopple bounced around from idea to idea, going from the Old Yankee Stadium memories, to opinions of the new Yankee Stadium, to historic former and current Yankees, to random fans.

Many of the people interviewed by Kopple sounded uncomfortable and forced into speaking. Kopple herself had possibly the most annoying voice ever, and spoke often during the film as an interviewer.

The film had another flaw in that it never gave one true opinion on Steinbrenner. Throughout the film he was portrayed as giving, ruthless, emotional, unpatient, among others. Those adjectives do not fit together.

The film was awkward at many points, as Hal Steinbrenner seemed to not want to speak to Kopple and seemed annoyed by the whole situation. His failed attempts at making jokes were not edited out, they were included at random points in the film.

Kopple promoted herself as much as the Yankees and Steinbrenners and just made herself look worse. The 30 for 30 was dissaponting, but I do suggest watching it. Despite the confusing set-up of the film, it does include highlights from the Old Yankee Stadium, and highlights of The Boss. I give it a 4 out of 10.

Poll
Which stadium do you like better?
Old Yankee Stadium
124 votes
New Yankee Stadium
43 votes
Neither are satisfactory and are equal in enjoyment
6 votes
Both are satisfactory and equal in enjoyment
61 votes

234 votes | Poll has closed

6 comments  | 

The buried Ortiz jersey

Photo

Remember the construction worker who buried a David Ortiz jersey in the cement of the new Yankee Stadium? How's he feeling about now?

Since the Yankees moved into the supposedly jinxed ballpark, three things have happened: David Ortiz was exposed as a PED user, he had his worst year season since joining the Red Sox, and the Yankees won the World Series in their first year at the new digs.

There's just one thing to say to Gino Castignoli... thanks!

4 comments  | 

Something about new ballparks

Photo

The first Yankee Stadium was built in 1923. The Yankees won the World Series (for the first time) over the New York Giants that year.

The first year of the 'overhauled' Yankee Stadium was 1976. The Yanks won the pennant (for the first time in 12 years), but lost the World Series to the Big Red Machine.

The first year of the new Yankee Stadium was 2009. The Yankees defeated the Philadelphia Phillies to win their 27th title (for the first time in nine years).

What are the odds?

(The '09 Yanks also became the third team to win the clinching game of the World Series in their new ballpark, joining the 1912 Red Sox and 2006 Cardinals.)

11 comments  | 

Remember this place?

The sad, slow deconstruction of the old Yankee Stadium continues. Below is a photo of the facade being taken apart. See WCBS880.com for more images.

5048851_medium

via imgsrv.wcbs880.com

7 comments  | 

Getting used to the new place

That was a surreal game last night. I was sitting there in the third inning thinking, 'Wow. This is the new Yankee Stadium. I've lived my whole life watching the old one 81 times a year. Who's stadium is this? It looks like one of those new-fangled ones that teams out west are always building.'

But by the middle innings, I started getting used to it. And then it struck me that for most of us, this is the last Yankee Stadium we'll ever see. If this one lasts 75 years like the previous one, this will be the Yankees home for the rest of our lives.

Anyway, the crowd wasn't too loud, but that was mostly due to the weather and the insignificance of the game (I'm sure). But Pete Abraham brings some disturbing news:

The highly-touted manual scoreboards set inside the wall in right field and left field are almost useless. The numbers are too small to see from the stands. The out-of-town scoreboard is in right field now. Only four games at a time, however.

... you can’t see the retired numbers in Monument Park like you used to be able to. There should be somewhere where everybody can see them. Retired numbers should be celebrated, not hidden away...

The Yankees, unfortunately, didn’t change the in-game entertainment very much. The same old lame YMCA, etc....

... it won’t be a very intimidating park for opposing players. The fans are not on top of the field like they used to be.

As far as the field goes, the infield seemed extremely fast (especially considering the rain). Those first two grounders the Cubs hit rocketed past Jeter and Cano.

The ball carried extraordinarily well to left-center field. Several fly balls that looked like 'cans of corn' sent fielders almost to the warning track. Only time will tell if these are real characteristics or just flukes (or perhaps something about different camera angles).

Homeruns clanged off each of the foul poles. The baseball gods were with the Yanks last night, let's hope they stay there.

Another game today at 1 p.m. on YES. What are your thoughts on the new place?

8 comments  | 

Before the game, take a tour

Tonight's game (if the rain lets up) is on YES and MLBN at 7 p.m.

 

  • Isn't this photo of Phil Hughes facing Jose Tabata from Wednesday's minor league game (taken by the venerable Chad Jennings) phenomenal? It's eerily reminiscent of their infamous meeting in the 2006 Futures Game (which has unfortunately been removed from YouTube) in which Tabata nearly took Hughes' head off with a line drive.

Hughes-and-tabata-3-_2800_4_2d00_1_2900__medium

5 comments  | 

Workout at the new Stadium

The Yankees moved into their new home today and worked out in preparation for two exhibition games against the Cubs.

  • Hal Steinbrenner admitted some of the ticket prices may be a bit high.
  • Another example of the resurgence of defense.
  • Doc's Sports Blog interviewed me regarding the upcoming season. It was definitely tougher questions than the normal fluff interview. 
  • Bernie Williams recently released a CD entitled "Moving Forward" that I was fortunate to listen to. It's clear from the very start that Bernie is a super talented guy. Not only was he a great ball player, but the fact he can play the guitar so expertly says a lot about him. If 'contemporary jazz' is your thing, you'll love it. Even though it's not mine, I still enjoyed it, and loved 'Take Me Out To The Ballgame' and Bernie's collaboration with Bruuuuuuuce on 'Glory Days'.

3 comments  | 


User Tools

Welcome to Pinstripe Alley, an SB Nation blog about the 27-time World Champion New York Yankees.

Community Guidelines

Managers

Mo_rivera_small Travis G

Nsapcs7_extr_small Brandon C.

Writers

Moar_bacon_small Lord Duggan

V5zevr_small WhatwouldJeterdo

Costanza_small I'mGivingYouARaise

Picture_2_small Frank Campagnola

Cone_coffeez_small Andrew GM

Derek-jeter-1_small Chris McKeown

T128_small Rob Steingall

Don-mattingly_small williamnyy