I put together a 5 man rotation and 3 relievers. I based this only on stats as Yankees . By the way because of the big debate on Pt1. I gave Pettite a chance to make the staff based on stats only. He would have been ranked 10th out of 11 starters.
#1 - Whitey Ford
#2 - Jack Chesbro
#3 - Ron Guidry
#4 - Mel Stottlemeyer
#5 - Bob Shawkey
Right Handed Set Up Man - Goose Gossage
Left Handed Set Up Man - Sparky Lyle
Closer - Mariano Rivera
My thinking for the Bullpen is that Lyle and Gossage came in earlier and worked through the 9th. They would be considered now the lefty and righty set up men.
Let the debate begin.