PA Book Club: Living On the Black (Part 1)
I'm well along in Living on the Black, our last book club read for the offseason, and I have a few thoughts.
For the moment, let's focus on the first 8 chapters, which takes us to the opening of Spring Training.
1) I believe I read this book. I was working at a book store in Scranton when it came out, and I'm sure I've at least read the beginning.
2) I must have been unimpressed. I'm certainly unimpressed by the first 100+ pages of the book. In a way, I'm not sure it's author John Feinstein's fault; the book is clearly written to give the casual sports fan a deeper understanding of the work that goes into pitching. I think it does this well. But there's no second level that makes the book a rewarding read to a die hard.
3) Living on the Black is only aimed at the casual sports fan (or someone who doesn't remember 2007). This book is for the guy who only tunes into a dozen baseball games a year. There's not a lot in this book for fans like us-who lived and died with each game, poured over multiple recaps and dissected every quote as it was delivered.
Am I wrong about this? Moose is easily my favorite Yankee pitcher of my lifetime (non-Rivera division). I spent a lot of time thinking about how he was doing and how he might get better. I come into the book with a wealth of knowledge and a ton of bias. But there's nothing in the Mussina chapters that engage me.
I know a lot less about Tom Glavine. I mean, Hall of Fame, Braves and somehow-Mets, best or second best lefty of his generation, a finesse pitcher. I wasn't familiar with the details of how he wound up in Flushing, his path to the major leagues, or any of the back story of his life. On the other hand, I felt like that entire section of the book could have been done in 5-10 pages, instead of the 100 pages it took.
Have you learned anything about pitching from Living on the Black? What do you see that's wonderful that I'm missing?
11 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
this doesn't necessarily relate but...
you live(d) in/around scranton??? i’ve attened the U for the past 4 years….miss that place
I lived there for a year, taught English at Keystone and Johnson College right after I finished my master’s. I lived on East Gibson is a scummy little apartment whose best feature was being walking distance from downtown.
I loved Scranton- great Thai, good bars, and a couple really nice Italian restaurants. Plus, that was the first or second year the Yanks’ AAA team was there, so I went to a few games.
"Have faith in the Yankees, my son. Think of the great DiMaggio."
I would have
to disagree, I enjoyed this book, but then again I just finished ‘The Last Boy’ and thought it was pretty bad.
Hey, that’s fine- we can like different things.
Maybe the book will pick up for me once the season gets going (Mussina just hit the DL and Glavine’s getting ready to pitch in Atlanta.
"Have faith in the Yankees, my son. Think of the great DiMaggio."
I saw The Last Boy
at Barnes and Noble this weekend. It was $30 though. Little too rich for the college kid who was there to buy his little sister a birthday present
I believe in the Church of Baseball
Free FreeBradshaw!
by Frank Campagnola on Feb 2, 2011 7:14 PM EST up reply actions
Also, the majority of the book can be read here. Some pages are omitted, but when you’re a college kid, free > not free.
Its still something I'd like for my bookshelf
I have Damn Yankees, Perfect I’m Not, and Paul O’Neil’s Me and My Dad
I believe in the Church of Baseball
Free FreeBradshaw!
by Frank Campagnola on Feb 4, 2011 12:22 AM EST up reply actions
My copy is on a Nookshelf
The e-book was ~$12, IIRC.
Usqueadbaugham! Anam muck an dhoul ! Did ye drink me doornail?
It's a good read and I gained some baseball knowledge...read on
I especially liked how Moose and Glavine discusses pitcher psyche, dealing with adversary, and having to make constant adjustments as they got older.
I'm glad you stopped at chapter eight for today's post.
That’s exactly where I am. I’m traveling a lot right now, and the book (I got the hardback copy as a bargain book) is too big to fit in my laptop case.
I felt the first eight chapters were a bit of a chore, myself, but that’s because they’re entirely background for the rest of the book, and largely familiar background, to boot. Mostly, I think he’s motivating why readers should care about following Glavine and Mussina for a whole season. This fits in with the suggestion that his audience comprises casual fans; I just wonder if that matches the actual readership of the book.
Since it has been entirely back story up to this point, though, I’m eager to continue.
Usqueadbaugham! Anam muck an dhoul ! Did ye drink me doornail?





































