Farm system recap: Scranton Yankees, aka A Farewell to A-Jax
With all the recent events between the Yankees and their division rivals, this had to be delayed.
The Triple-A Yankees finished first in the International League's Northern Division with an 81-60 record. They were swept, however, in the IL finals by the Durham Bulls, three games to none.
The offensive star was once again Shelley Duncan, who won the MVP after hitting .277/.370/.546 and leading the league in homers and RBI. He'll be 30 next year and declined to return to the Scranton Yankees, making himself a free agent. It's too bad that he happened to be in the organization of a team with such talent at the big league level. I believe he could've been (and still might be) a productive ML hitter.
Cuban defector Juan Miranda was the left-handed MVP, batting .290/.369/.498. He's been called the current DH for the big league Yankees, but we all should remember Brian Cashman's statement that Bubba Crosby was the starting centerfielder right before they signed Johnny Damon. However, having Miranda as the platoon DH/1B wouldn't be so bad. He murders right-handed pitchers (.893 OPS vs. RHP, .712 vs. LHP). But having a DH that only plays two-thirds of the games makes for problems by itself. He's a solid insurance policy in case (Mo forbid) Teixeira goes down.
The best prospect on Scranton was Austin Jackson (.300/.354/.405), who led the team in plate appearances because he hit lead-off much of the year. He's what's called a 'toolsy' prospect, basically meaning he hasn't shown much in terms of production but has the raw tools to be a very good player. His best stint to date was a half-season with the Tampa Yankees (.345/.398/.566 in 67 games). However, he has never come close to that incredible slugging average since 2007 (.419 and .405 the two years since). What's also concerning (for Detroit) is his strikeout rate: 522 in 565 career games. Generally a player that K's that much also hits for power - not so with Ajax, who has 30 career homers. The Tigers are hoping that his raw physical ability eventually translates into power (he'll only be 23 next year). He hits for a decent average (.288) and OBP (.356), steals bases (123 SB, 34 CS) and plays above-average defense (by most accounts). He'll never be a superstar, but could be a good centerfielder for many years (which is extremely valuable).
There wasn't anyone too exciting on the pitching side. Romulo Sanchez (65 ip, 4.04 ERA, 64 K, 34 BB, 1.55 WHIP) was acquired from the Pirates in May. The Yankees like his high-90's velocity, but what's perplexing is his relative lack of K's (until this year). He K'ed 5.9/9 before this season. That rate jumped to 9.2/9 this year. Being just 25, he still has a chance at a long ML career. He'll never have a rotation spot, but his heat could make him an intriguing bullpen option in 2010.
Another relief option is Mark Melancon (53 ip, 2.89 ERA, 54 K, 11 BB, .91 WHIP), the former closer for the U. of Arizona. His career minor league stats are sick: 156 ip, 2.54 ERA, 151 K, 35 BB, .96 WHIP. His problem at the major league level, in a brief 13-game stint, was control: he walked 10 in 16 innings. That can be attributed mostly to nerves. His MiL walk rate is very low (2/9), so once he gets comfortable in the majors, we should see the dominant Mark Melancon.
I guess I need to mention He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named, who now holds Scranton's career mark for wins, with 29. He led the team in innings (145), wins (10), K's (105), walks (40) and homers allowed (21). Two years to go...
0 recs |
15 comments
|
Comments
Shelley Duncan...
He’ll be 30 next year and declined to return to the Scranton Yankees, making himself a free agent. It’s too bad that he happened to be in the organization of a team with such talent at the big league level. I believe he could’ve been (and still might be) a productive ML hitter.
If that were true, someone would have asked for him in a trade at some point during his Yankee career. He’s AAAA, no more, no less.
by New York Sports Jerk on Dec 16, 2009 11:17 AM EST reply actions
I have to agree. He was great in 07 when he came up and was hitting bombs, but he cant hit an offspeed pitch. If he was anything worth getting excited about someone would have traded for him. Why nothing on Ramiro Pena?
AAA pitchers,
believe it or not, can throw quality offspeed pitches. no, he won’t be a star, but a productive platoon player is not out of the question.
i didn’t mention Ramiro bc he only played 43 games for Scranton (and did nothing of note besides hitting poorly).
AAA pitchers...
…who throw quality breaking stuff become MLB pitchers fairly quickly. I know you love Shelley Duncan, but again, if he was any good, the Yankees would have dealt him at some point to a team who wanted him to play at the major league level.
He’s 30. It’s over for him as far as a big league career goes.
And you talk about small sample sizes, in his first 9 games at the MLB level, he OPS’d 1.263.
For the rest of 2007 OPS – .650
2008 OPS – .542
He had a week and a half when he tore the cover off the ball. Once he stopped seeing fastballs, he barely touched it.
by New York Sports Jerk on Dec 16, 2009 3:30 PM EST up reply actions
don't exaggerate or anything
show me where i said i ‘love’ Shelley Duncan. loving a guy and thinking he could be a productive MLer are rather different.
his entire ML career consists of 146 AB. that’s hardly enough to make a sound judgment.
he has never slugged under .400, and has slugged over .450 7 times in 9 seasons. he deserves a real shot. the Yankees have not given him one (understandably with their stacked lineup).
It's the only explanation...
…for thinking that a 30-year-old career minor leaguer who has never once been the subject of a trade request could possibly be productive at the major league level.
You know who else tore up the minor leagues? Andy Phillips.
You know who couldn’t hit major league pitching? Andy Phillips.
He had a higher slugging and higher OPS in his minor league career than Duncan. Some guys just are not major league hitters.
The “sound judgement” you speak of has already been made by dozens of scouts from every team. If they thought he could be productive at the ML level, the Yankees would have traded him in a heartbeat just to get some kind of return.
They didn’t, because nobody wants him.
by New York Sports Jerk on Dec 16, 2009 8:23 PM EST up reply actions
basing
your whole opinion on ‘scouts dont want him’ is wrong. the Yanks offered Robbie Cano and CM Wang for RJ back in 05, but the Dbacks turned them down in favor of Dioner Navarro and Brad Halsey. scouts make mistakes.
Yeah, the scouts are wrong...
…and you’re right.
Duncan was DFA in January, and wasn’t claimed. He was DFA again after this year, and wasn’t claimed.
And your example doesn’t even work in defending your opinion. The scouts have had 10 years to watch Duncan, they had far less time to evaluate Navarro and Halsey, who at that point were both more highly thought of than Cano and Wang.
Besides that, you’re talking about 1 team’s scouts, that made the right decision based on the age and production of the players you mentioned in the minors. I’m talking about 30 teams looking at a guy who is 30 years old and saying, “nah.”
But whatever, I’m sure you’re seeing things in Shelley Duncan’s swing that suggest that he’s suddenly going to be able to hit breaking pitches at the major league level. It’s not an insult to call him a AAAA player.
by New York Sports Jerk on Dec 16, 2009 9:23 PM EST up reply actions
Second that
He had a chance in 2008, but failed to produce, resulting in .175/ .262/ .281 in 65 ABs. Not Kei Igawa bad, but not good.
Small Sample Size Alert!
65 AB ain’t enough to make any conclusions about Shelley, or any player for that matter. that’s less than one month of AB.
I know but
how many at bats are you doing to give someone who is that far south of the Mendoza Line? Expectations that year were that Shelly was going see some playing time.
5ys $25 million
for player that high on all the career stat lists? That’s a steal IMO……
Why couldn’t we pay him $50 mill, after we pay $50 to sit down and talk to him?
"It ain't over till its over"---
3rd down + Steve Smith = 1st Down.

by 






















